If your stocking-stuffer list or White Elephant gift pile is running low on "actually interesting," we just added something new: a pair of solid brass Mothman challenge coins inspired by the legendary 1966 sightings in Point Pleasant, West Virginia. They're small, weird in the best way, and priced exactly where a great stocking stuffer or Secret Santa steal should land.
The legend behind the coin
Late on the night of November 15, 1966, two young couples driving near the old TNT area outside Point Pleasant reported a winged figure with glowing red eyes caught in their headlights. That sighting kicked off one of America's most enduring cryptid legends — one that's been retold in books, documentaries, and campfire stories for nearly 60 years, and that still draws visitors to Point Pleasant every year.
We turned that story into two different coins, each with its own take on the legend.
Mothman Art Deco Coin — "In Strangeness We Trust"
This one leans into the Jazz Age: a geometric Mothman with spread wings, glowing eyes, and sunburst rays on one side, framed by a stepped art deco border. Flip it over and you get the motto IN STRANGENESS WE TRUST in bold 1920s-style lettering, bordered by stars and skyscraper lines. It's less "crime scene" and more "vintage pocket token for someone who likes cryptids and old-school design in equal measure."
See the full details and order yours on the Mothman Art Deco Coin product page.
Mothman TNT Area Encounter Coin — Point Pleasant, Nov 15, 1966
This coin is the storyteller of the two. Headlights shine up from the bottom edge as Mothman rises between the concrete igloo bunkers that still stand in the old TNT area today. The light rays are raised, tapering bands that actually catch the light as you turn the coin in your hand. Flip it over for a vintage-style map fragment of the TNT area, marked with a small "X" and the date NOV 15, 1966 — the night it all started.
Check it out on the Mothman TNT Area Encounter Coin product page.
Why these make a great gift
- Stocking stuffers: at 40mm across and 3mm thick, they slide into a stocking with room to spare — and at $25 each, they don't blow the stocking-stuffer budget.
- White Elephant & Secret Santa: genuinely weird, genuinely cool, and priced right in the sweet spot most office gift exchanges cap out at. These are the gifts people fight over instead of re-gifting.
- Collectors: challenge coin and token collectors, cryptid and paranormal enthusiasts, and anyone who's made the pilgrimage to Point Pleasant will recognize exactly what they're holding.
- Desk or EDC piece: solid brass, double-sided, and substantial enough to be a daily pocket carry or a conversation-starter on a desk.
Both coins are solid brass, so they'll naturally develop a warm patina over time if you let them age, or stay bright with an occasional polish with brass cleaner and a soft cloth — whichever look you're after.
Starting a collection
Since each coin tells a different half of the story — one the mythology, one the moment — they're built to be collected as a pair. Grab both and you've got a complete little tribute to one of America's strangest nights, ready to wrap, stuff in a stocking, or drop into a gift exchange that needs to win.
These are original designs inspired by the Point Pleasant, West Virginia Mothman legend and American folklore. They are not affiliated with, licensed by, or endorsed by any book, film, or franchise.